Endurance Car Warranty Review 2024

In today's automotive market, extended auto warranties are essential for protecting against unexpected repair costs. Endurance is a leading provider in this industry, known for its comprehensive coverage plans and customer-oriented services. This review evaluates Endurance's offerings, customer service, pricing, and more, providing a thorough understanding for potential customers.

Overview of Endurance

Founded in 2006, Endurance Warranty Services has grown into a significant player in the extended auto warranty market. Based in Northbrook, Illinois, the company is known for its direct-to-consumer model, which eliminates the need for third-party administrators. This approach helps streamline processes and maintain a higher level of customer service.

Coverage Plans

Select Premier

The Select Premier plan is tailored for high-mileage vehicles, covering essential components such as the engine, transmission, drive axle, cooling system, and electrical systems. This plan is ideal for older cars, providing crucial protection for significant parts.


The Secure plan is the most basic and affordable option, covering essential powertrain components like the engine, transmission, and drive axle. It's suitable for those seeking basic but vital coverage without extra frills.

Secure Plus

Secure Plus expands on the Secure plan by including additional coverage for the air conditioning, electrical, and fuel systems, as well as brake components. This mid-tier plan offers a balance between cost and coverage.


The Superior plan provides extensive coverage for almost all major and minor components, including high-tech and electrical systems. It’s perfect for newer vehicles or those with advanced technology features.


The Supreme plan offers exclusionary coverage, similar to a manufacturer’s warranty. It covers nearly all vehicle components, excluding only those specifically listed. This top-tier plan is ideal for new or luxury vehicles, providing the highest level of protection.

Pricing and Value

Cost Structure

Endurance’s pricing is influenced by factors such as the vehicle’s make, model, age, and mileage. Typically, older and higher-mileage vehicles incur higher costs. However, Endurance’s competitive pricing and flexible payment plans make their warranties accessible to a wide range of customers.

Payment Options

Endurance offers various payment plans, including interest-free options. Customers can choose to pay upfront or spread the cost over monthly payments, making it easier to fit different budgets.

Cost vs. Benefit Analysis

The initial cost of an Endurance warranty can be substantial, but the potential savings on major repairs often justify the expense. The comprehensive coverage provided by higher-tier plans, such as Supreme, offers significant peace of mind and financial protection.

Claims Process

Filing a Claim

Endurance has a streamlined claims process designed for ease of use. Customers can file claims online or via a dedicated customer service hotline. The process involves diagnosing the issue, obtaining repair estimates, and securing authorization for covered repairs.

Customer Experience

Most customers report positive experiences with the claims process, noting the efficiency and helpfulness of support staff. However, some challenges exist, particularly regarding understanding coverage details and occasional delays.

Claims Approval and Denial

While Endurance strives to approve legitimate claims quickly, some denials occur due to issues like pre-existing conditions or inadequate maintenance records. Customers are encouraged to thoroughly understand their plan’s coverage to avoid such issues.

Customer Service

Availability and Support

Endurance provides 24/7 customer support, ensuring help is available whenever needed. This round-the-clock availability is a significant benefit, especially for emergencies.

Customer Feedback

Customer feedback on Endurance’s service is generally positive. Many customers praise the company’s helpful and knowledgeable representatives. However, some have reported frustrations with wait times and the resolution process for complex issues.

Pros and Cons


  • Comprehensive Coverage: Wide range of plans tailored to different needs.
  • 24/7 Customer Support: Ensures assistance is always available.
  • Direct-to-Consumer Model: Simplifies the process by eliminating third-party administrators.
  • Flexible Payment Options: Accommodates different budgets.


  • Cost: Extended warranties can be expensive, particularly for older vehicles.
  • Claims Denial: Some customers report issues with claim denials due to misunderstandings of coverage.
  • Mixed Reviews: Customer experiences vary, with some reporting excellent service and others facing challenges.

Competitor Comparison

Endurance vs. CARCHEX

Coverage: Both offer similar plans, but Endurance’s direct-to-consumer model simplifies the process.

Pricing: CARCHEX may have slightly lower prices, but Endurance’s flexible payment options provide better value.

Customer Service: Both companies receive mixed reviews, but Endurance’s 24/7 support is a significant advantage.

Endurance vs. CarShield

Coverage: CarShield offers a broader range of plans, but Endurance’s Supreme plan is more comprehensive.

Pricing: CarShield is often more affordable, but Endurance provides better value for comprehensive coverage.

Customer Service: CarShield has more mixed reviews compared to Endurance’s generally positive feedback.

Endurance vs. Protect My Car

Coverage: Protect My Car includes maintenance services in some plans, which Endurance does not.

Pricing: Protect My Car’s pricing is competitive, but Endurance’s extensive coverage options offer significant value.

Customer Service: Both companies have similar customer service ratings, though Endurance’s direct model offers a smoother experience.

Real Customer Reviews

Positive Experiences

Many customers appreciate Endurance’s comprehensive coverage and customer service. Reviews often highlight the peace of mind provided by extensive protection plans and the helpfulness of customer service representatives. The ease of filing claims and the prompt payment for covered repairs are frequently praised.

Negative Experiences

Negative reviews commonly mention issues with claim denials and misunderstandings about what is covered. Some customers report frustration with the claims process and the time it takes to get repairs approved. Others express dissatisfaction with the cost of the plans, particularly when unexpected expenses arise.


Endurance stands out in the extended auto warranty industry for its comprehensive coverage plans, flexible payment options, and 24/7 customer support. While the cost can be high, especially for older vehicles, the peace of mind and financial protection it offers can be well worth the investment. Customers considering an extended auto warranty should thoroughly understand their coverage options and read the fine print to avoid misunderstandings. Overall, Endurance is a strong contender in the market, providing valuable protection for a wide range of vehicles and budgets.


Based on reviews from multiple sources, including Trustpilot and other review platforms, Endurance holds a solid reputation:

  • Trustpilot: 4.3 out of 5 stars from over 4,700 reviews.
  • BBB: 3.2 out of 5 stars based on customer reviews.
  • AutoGuide: Recognized for the best coverage in 2024 with high marks for their Supreme plan.

Overall Rating: 9.4/10

Endurance offers robust coverage options, flexible payment plans, and reliable customer service, making them a leading choice for extended auto warranties. Their direct-to-consumer model and comprehensive coverage plans contribute to their high rating, despite some areas for improvement in claims processing and customer satisfaction.

CompareOffers.com Staff
Written by CompareOffers.com Staff

The CompareOffers.com editorial team is a dedicated group of professionals committed to providing accurate and insightful reviews to help consumers make informed decisions. Our team combines extensive research, expert analysis, and user feedback to offer comprehensive comparisons across a variety of products and services. With backgrounds in finance, technology, and consumer advocacy, we aim to simplify the decision-making process by delivering clear and unbiased information. Our mission is to empower consumers with the knowledge they need to choose the best options available in the market.